It means installation of various packages and working with them is easier in Protractor. It does not specify any specific technology based web applications. and it would now be easier for you to choose the better tool for your requirements and the winner in Protractor vs selenium will change according to it. It is matured, contains a complete API and has more features than just browser based tasks. Selenium directly interacts with the browser and retrieves the results. The current version 2.25.0 is fully powered to support Java, C#, PHP, Python, Ruby and PERL and to perform tests of difficult level too. Cross-browser testing is a lot easier because Protractor is based on the Selenium WebDriver. This blog post gives a comprehensive comparison of Selenium and Protractor, and lets you understand when to choose which tool and the reasons behind it. To interact with browser, WebDriver uses the Selenium JSON-Wire-Protocol. JavaScript- WebDriverJS, WebDriverIO. Gain expertise by taking expert training on this evergreen and most demanded automated testing tools at GangBoard, the expert in IT and software training and certifications in Chennai and Bangalore. Runs on both real browsers and headless browsers. Selenium WebDriver. It like comparing apples and pumpkins. Protractor needs to install webdriver-manager to run the Selenium server (almost every e2e tool uses Selenium). Their expert trainers hail from reputed MNCs and have vast real-time experience in working with such tools. Similar to RC, WebDriver too supports Java, C#, PHP, Python, Ruby and PERL. Since Protractor has node at its core, wide variety of packages can be installed as and when needed. Where as Selenium is developed for any Web Browser Automation. It is Node.js program. Using Protractor with Selenium is better if one needs to carry out full E2E testing that opens a browser and executes a DOM manipulation. Supports Automatic wait for Angular applications, but they are not applicable for Non-angular applications. We install protractor executing the command: npm install -g protractor. Selenium Vs Katalon Studio – Learn the Ways to Simplify Selenium Tests in Katalon Studio (with a login test case hands-on example on both the tools) Automated testing is a technique that uses an application to conduct the testing process for another application. Well, for all of you who can’t wait till the end of the blog – The “Testing Oscar” for the fastest execution and best performance for the tested scenario goes to: Headless Chrome, Selenium WebDriverand Java with only 1820ms per execution!!! © 2020- BDreamz Global Solutions. Official website of Selenium says that:- Selenium automates browser. Protractor got inbuilt waits for angular and ajax calls, but we have to define the waits in selenium to handle angular and ajax. Selenium can be used to automate any technology based application which needs a browser. 21 Best API Testing Tools That are insanely good –, Difference between functional testing and non functional testing, Difference between regression testing and retesting, Difference Between White box and Black box Testing, Difference between use case and test case, Difference between smoke testing and sanity testing, Difference between load testing and stress testing, Agile VS DevOps: Difference between Agile and DevOps. Protractor vs selenium who will win? Protractor is suitable for both Angular and Non-Angular web applications. Also, Protractor runs equally well with real browsers and headless browsers. Both are used to automate Angular Applications. Protractor vs. selenium speed is not comparable as their strategies are different. Protractor, the genuine testing framework for AngularJS, is written in JavaScript too. We Offers most popular Software Training Courses with Practical Classes, Real world Projects and Professional trainers from India. And the slowest performance was observed with Cypress execution. The webdriver-manager is a helper tool used by Protractor. We Offer Best Online Training on AWS, Python, Selenium, Java, Azure, Devops, RPA, Data Science, Big data Hadoop, FullStack developer, Angular, Tableau, Power BI and more with Valid Course Completion Certificates. As Protractor is specially designed for angular applications, so if you are testing angular applications, it is better to opt for a protractor. This open source end-to-end testing framework offers the following advantages − An open source tool, Protractor is … 3. Setting Up Protractor; Setting Up the Selenium Server; Setting Up the Browser; Choosing a Framework; Protractor Tests . Not easy, a lot of sync issues and difficult to find real wait conditions. Advantages. You need lesser number of code lines for testing with Selenium. Requires third-party tools:- protractor-beautiful-reporter, protractor-HTML-reporter etc. Java- JUnit, TestNG Now go ahead and spot the difference between the two canonical examples: Protractor (9 lines of code, not including the comments): Selenium (17, longer, lines of code, not including the comments): Don't let the Lockdown slow you Down - Enroll Now and Get 2 Course at $398/- Only It also supports Java, C#, PHP, Python, Ruby, and PERL. It’s API is quite matured and supports extra features to assists tasks beyond even browser-based tasks. Getting Started; Tutorial; Working with Spec and Config Files; Setting Up the System Under Test; Using Locators; Using Page Objects to Organize Tests; Debugging Protractor Tests; Reference . Protractor is an all in one powerful testing tool for end-to-end testing of web applications. To achieve the best testing results, it is very important to choose the most appropriate testing tool according to your requirements. Protractor vs Selenium. It provides a modern and steady way to test web applications. The protractor is provided with Jasmine as a default framework. Protractor also has a high capability to write automated regressions tests for web applications. We can create customization from Selenium in creating Angular JS apps, Protractor can run on top of selenium giving all the advantages of Selenium, You can use API exposed by Webdriver and Angular, Uses the same web driver as that of Selenium. C#, Java, Haskell, Perl. Ye… oh – great, let’s see now: One more addition that makes life easier for users is globals. It is made for angular applications hence it is easy to automate Angular Applications. also permits the creation of custom locators. Selenium is an open source testing tool for performing automated testing on web applications. No new verticals for browser automation are developed as such. By now you would have been pretty clear about the differences in both. Protractor use angular based locator such as ng-model, ng-binding, ng-repeat as well as selenium web driver locators ( id, name, class, XPath) to identify the … However, one has some features that make it supreme to the other. Selenium is an all-inclusive suite that is licensed under Apache License 2.0. Protractor with Selenium The main advantage of using this is time saving and faster execution. Blog Software Testing Selenium vs Protractor. New entrée in the market and needs expertise to work with. No official support operates on open community model. But you can explicitly synchronize waits in Protractor. • Code length is more because all of the fetch operation return promise so you got to solve the promises first, so the code length is … Jmeter Tutorial: Learn about the tool in a jiffy! WebDriver is also the official JavaScript implementation of Selenium. It assists in quick and easy testing on various browsers. A major drawback with Selenium looking at TestComplete vs Selenium is that it does not check if the images are displayed or not. It interacts with browser by directly communicating with it and retrieving the results. Protractor runs tests against your application running in a real browser, interacting with it as a user would. 3. This is just a wrapper developed over WebDriver JS. View Disclaimer. Though it is specially designed for AngularJS applications, it works equally well for other applications as well. Yes. So the command line takes care for us. Here are the basic points of differences between Selenium and Protractor: Based on language binding, it supports various Test Frameworks C#- NUnit, Do something as long as element is on page - cypress. Regardless of its benefits, the question of comparing TestComplete vs Selenium will always stand. Because of the parallel execution feature, it allows executing test cases in multiple instances of the browser simultaneously. Cypress vs. Selenium (2) Comparison of different characteristics: Screenshot – both perform equally bad because both make screenshot only of the visible part of the page. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. On the other hand, Selenium is a browser automation framework that includes the Selenium Server, the WebDriver APIs and the WebDriver browser drivers. Protractor works well with Jasmine and Mocha frameworks. All Rights Reserved. Loạt bài viết này trích từ khóa học Protractor E2E Testing – bạn nào quan tâm và muốn làm bài bản thì nên tham gia để học và thá»±c hành từ A-Z nhé.. Bài viết đầu tiên so sánh sá»± khác nhau giữa Selenium vs Protractor … The main advantage of using this is time saving and faster execution. Selenium will need a professional engineer who is technically sound to write its web driver scripts. AngularJS was designed from ground up to be testable. If you want to create robust, browser-based regression automation suites and tests, scale and distribute scripts across many environments, then you want to use Selenium WebDriver, a collection of language specific bindings to drive a browser - the way it is meant to be driven. Comparing the performance selenium is faster than Protractor on the normal application, but protractor is faster than selenium in angular application. Though Selenium can do some of the things what protractor does, the protractor is the industrial standard and best practice to test AngularJS applications. Protractor supports various cloud testing platforms like SauceLabs and CrossBrowserTesting, etc. Protractor is an end-to-end test framework for Angular and AngularJS applications. Protractor Setup . Works well with Angular pages too; however page synchronization issues may crop up. Ex: Type Script and Java Script. A Protractor can also manage multiple capabilities in it and handle the dynamic changes of web elements using ng-model, ng-click.., etc.. (Which selenium cannot do). If the budget allows, TestComplete can become a great tool for a team of less skilled developers. Step 4 − At last, the browser APIs are invoked with the help of Selenium WebDriver. This is a Firefox plugin that testers use to record their sequence of work flow. During Protractor execution you no longer need to add waits specifically to wait for your next test. The languages supported by Selenium are Java, Python Kotlin, C, C#, PHP. Selenium WebDriver is an advanced version of Selenium RC. It works as a Solution integrator by assimilating the dominant technologies like Jasmine, Cucumber, Selenium, NodeJS, Web driver, etc. Does not support automatic synchronization between tests and application. Selenium is widely established and proven one, and Protractor is emerging in the market as of now. Mocha,  Jasmine, Cucumber and Serenity/JS. The certification names are the trademarks of their respective owners. Working with multiple assertion libraries is possible with Protractor. Testers can run Protractor on their code deployed in. 🥇⚡ The second place goes to TestProject! Official website of Protractor says that: Protractor is an end-to-end test framework for Angular and AngularJS applications. In this example, selenium takes twice the time of protractor. It has some of the most basic features and is largely used for prototyping purposes. All that you need to take care is the configuration and the choice of browser. Protractor - Element not found. It needs to be explicitly synchronized using different waits. As such the comparison can be done as we have discussed in this post however, a decision about which tool to choose is based on many factors and a simple judgment can never be made in one word. Get In-depth knowledge through live Instructor Led Online Classes and Self-Paced Videos with Quality Content Delivered by Industry Experts. Working with multiple assertion libraries is possible with Protractor. This testing tool from Selenium is specifically designed for parallel execution of tests, simultaneously on multiple browsers and environments. Here are a few reasons to convince you to use Protractor: If the app you are developing is on AngularJSit’s always a better option to use Protractor since, Difference between Protractor vs Selenium. Both Selenium and Cucumber tools can be used for cross-browser web applications. Though Protractor is designed keeping in mind AngularJS applications, it performs with equal competence with non-AngularJS applications too. unable to run test cases in IE browser in protractor, selenium framework for angular.js web application. Study your requirements clearly and pick the aptest tool for more efficient testing results. And if you are the one, who is having a difficult time picking the aptest testing tool out of Selenium vs Protractor, then go ahead and read this article to find out a solution. All js related languages are supported by Protractor. An added benefit of WebDriver is that it does not require JavaScript for Automation. The main benefit of automation tools is faster execution and time-saving. Offers comprehensive support for all sorts of testing needs for web applications. Hot Network Questions It is faster than selenium because there is no need for any additional waits and sleeps. It is designed dedicatedly for web-based applications and is compatible across different browsers and platforms. All that you need to take care is the configuration and the choice of browser. Debugging in easy owing to Java based design. When it comes to choosing between Nightwatch vs Protractor, it is a tough call to take. Intrigued to know more about Selenium and Protractor?? Selenium - Web Browser Automation. Technically speaking software engineer cannot compare Selenium vs Protractor, because software engineer cannot compare suite of tools with framework. When working with Angular applications, protractor offers faster performance. Selenium is meant only for web-based applications and can be used across various browsers and platforms. Protractor performs equally good for both Angular and Non-Angular web applications. Python- PyUnit, PyTest It comes with a right mix of the power of NodeJS, Selenium WebDriver, Jasmine, Cucumber and Mocha – which makes it a preferred testing tool for web applications. Official website of Protractor says that:- Protractor is an end-to-end test framework for Angular and AngularJS applications. Protractor supports all … In order to get the full page, you need to use external JavaScript libraries to capture page and save it as a screenshot. Protractor comes as default tool for Angular projects. Protractor aids Jasmine and Mocha. In Selenium, Selenium Grid is responsible for the same. It is specially curated for parallel execution of tests, on various browsers and environments; it is based on the concept of hub and nodes. Both are used to automate Angular Applications. So, when creating larger applications the time difference output may be more in selenium. Protractor adds these objects to the global namespace: browser, element and by. Technical skills mandatory to work with this tool are Java and TestNG. Selenium Remote Control (RC) allows the testers to choose their preferred programming language. Your email address will not be published. Selenium Integrated Development Environment (IDE). Nightwatch vs Protractor vs Mocha : The Preferred Testing Framework By Hamid Akhtar, Community Contributor and Pradeep Krishnakumar, Manager - August 2, 2019 Amidst many commercial and open-source tools, Selenium is the most widely used open-source tool for automating testing suite for web applications across a range of platforms and browsers. Test Automation is the need of the hour and is widely adopted by the testing teams across the globe; to assist testers in automation testing several testing tools are now available in the markets. Supports common locator strategies like Id, className, name, linkText, tagName, partial link text, XPath and CSS  for all web applications. Debugging needs expertise and time consuming. Go ahead and All the best!! As Protractor is specially designed for angular applications, so if you are testing angular applications, it is better to opt for a protractor. Both Selenium and protractor are automated test tools for web applications. Selenium Remote Control (RC) is an automated web testing tool that gives the testers the choice to choose their preferred programming language. Talking in terms of Selenium WebDriver, Protractor is a wrapper developed on the top of webdriver.js, with added features and functionalities. Specially designed for Angular and AngularJS applications, but can be used for Non-angular applications also. Both the test automation tools are equally good. You can work in popular programming languages such as Python, Ruby, Java, Perl, C and C## . Although Protractor can be used for any non-angular application as well but the beauty of Protractor for Angular application will be missed. It is very easy to learn and use. Initially it was developed by Google developers and later converted into an open source framework. The framework is budding and harder comparatively. Protractor is designed specially for automating … The results are clear in the chart below, demonstrating the fastest execution … Protractor comes with parallel execution feature that lets a tester run test cases in multiple instances of the browser simultaneously. Selenium IDE is used to record the sequence of the workflow. Supports many frameworks of unit testing, such as TestNg and Junit. This Firefox plugin is easy to install and is also companionable with other plugins. This is also compatible on Windows and Linux. Selenium automates browser. Designed specifically for Angular pages and works with non-angular too without any issues. You Can take our training from anywhere in this world through Online Sessions and most of our Students from India, USA, UK, Canada, Australia and UAE. since the protractor track the network, router changes and execute the testing scripts accordingly. Requires third-party tools:- TestNG, Extent Report, Allure Report, etc. The learning curve is steep and hence the software cannot be entrusted to less skilled people in your team. As the slogan proudly says, AngularJSis what HTML would have been, had it been designed for building web-apps. The core functionality of Selenium Grid revolves around hub and nodes concept. Protractor works in conjunction with Selenium to provide an automated test infrastructure that can simulate a user’s interaction with an Angular application running in a browser or mobile device. In simple words working with packages is easier in Protractor. Requires third-party tools like  WebdriverManager to sync browser version and driver. Both Selenium and protractor are automated test tools for web applications. Step 3 − In this step, Selenium server will help to manage the browsers. Therefore, it’s interesting to know that the framework supports Selenium locators in protractors as well along with its own. It does not specify any specific technology based web applications. Another advantage with WebDriver is that is does not need JavaScript for Automation. Protractor is designed specially for automating Angular applications. You are just a call away from their expert counseling team and shaping your career! Proven, widely used for automation, well extended support and stable API. Requires web driver-manager CLI to automatic sync between browser version and driver for Chrome and Firefox. It runs the test—and the framework—just like a real user would. Sometimes, testers sometimes get stuck between two automation testing tools. Selenium’s performance is faster for a non-Angular web application. Angular Online Training and Certification Course, Java Online Training and Certification Course, Dot Net Online Training and Certification Course, Testcomplete Online Training and Certification Course, Salesforce Sharing and Visibility Designer Certification Training, Salesforce Platform App Builder Certification Training, Google Cloud Platform Online Training and Certification Course, AWS Solutions Architect Certification Training Course, SQL Server DBA Certification Training and Certification Course, Big Data Hadoop Certification Training Course, PowerShell Scripting Training and Certification Course, Azure Certification Online Training Course, Tableau Online Training and Certification Course, SAS Online Training and Certification Course, MSBI Online Training and Certification Course, Informatica Online Training and Certification Course, Informatica MDM Online Training and Certification Course, Ab Initio Online Training and Certification Course, Devops Certification Online Training and Course, Learn Kubernetes with AWS and Docker Training, Oracle Fusion Financials Online Training and Certification, Primavera P6 Online Training and Certification Course, Project Management and Methodologies Certification Courses, Project Management Professional Interview Questions and Answers, Primavera Interview Questions and Answers, Oracle Fusion HCM Interview Questions and Answers, AWS Solutions Architect Certification Training, PowerShell Scripting Training and Certification, Oracle Fusion Financials Certification Training, Oracle Performance Tuning Interview Questions. If the budget allows, TestComplete can become a great tool for a team less... Framework supports Selenium locators in protractors as well along with its own, it’s interesting to more. Driver, etc a wrapper developed over WebDriver JS on demand, you lesser! Says, AngularJSis what HTML would have been, had it been designed for building web-apps uses... Is one of the workflow next time I comment works great for testing AngularJS, is written in too... Than just browser based tasks are displayed or not Protractor when you are comfortable. Code and hence the software can not compare Selenium vs Protractor, Selenium, Selenium WebDriver is it! It been designed for Angular pages and works with non-angular too without any issues Projects and trainers. Will always stand WebDriver, Protractor offers faster performance capability to write its web driver, etc this! A Solution integrator by assimilating the dominant technologies like Jasmine, Cucumber, Selenium,,. And Angular waits using fluent wait in Selenium much speedier as it optimizes and... Achieve the best tools used in DevOps CICD process − in this example, Selenium, NodeJS, web scripts... It assists in quick and easy testing on web applications using the Selenium JSON-Wire-Protocol supports many frameworks of unit,! Basic features and many testers use this for prototyping purposes DOM manipulation offers most software... Multiple assertion libraries is possible with Protractor slogan proudly says, AngularJSis what HTML have... Drawback with Selenium Ye… oh – great, let’s see now: one more addition that makes easier. Selenium Integrated Development Environment ( IDE ), most Angular JS applications are embedded with automatic sync between version. Hail from reputed MNCs and have vast real-time experience in working with multiple assertion libraries is possible with Protractor emerging. Their preferred programming language application which needs a browser and retrieves the results are clear in the.. The testing scripts accordingly comfortable with handling the ajax and Angular waits using fluent wait Selenium! ), most Angular JS applications are embedded with knowledge through live Instructor Led Online and... Angular directives in a jiffy installed as and when needed in working with Angular pages and works non-angular... To handle Angular and non-angular web applications we offers most popular software Training Courses with Practical Classes, real Projects. Python, Ruby, and PERL with Angular directives in a real browser, element by. Different platforms and languages, Protractor offers faster performance can perform multiple browser testing on various browsers and environments a! Control ( RC ) is an end-to-end test framework mainly intended for Angular applications, it with! Write its web driver scripts many companies Angular waits using fluent wait Selenium. The main benefit of WebDriver is a wrapper developed over WebDriver JS in Angular specific locator strategy and perform!, and Protractor testing needs for web applications buying modules on demand, you need to take is. Their preferred programming language of choice frameworks of unit testing, such as TestNG and Junit around hub nodes. Looking at TestComplete vs Selenium will need a professional engineer who is technically sound to write its web driver etc! Is no need for any non-angular application as well along with its own means of... Instructor Led Online Classes and Self-Paced Videos with Quality Content Delivered by Industry Experts applications. Not applicable for non-angular applications also this is a modern and steady to... Automate Angular applications hence it is a modern and stable form of testing a application... Comes to Choosing between Nightwatch vs Protractor, because software engineer can not be entrusted to less skilled in! Was later turned into an open-source framework oh – great, let’s see now: more! And works with non-angular too without any issues − at last, the default is Jasmine plugin that use. Rc, Selenium WebDriver, Protractor offers faster performance Selenium ) much selenium vs protractor as optimizes... Can customize the pricing and leverage excellent technical support of choice no longer need use! Comfortable with handling the ajax and Angular waits using fluent wait in Selenium to handle and... Pretty clear about the differences in both programming language, let’s see now: one more addition that life... Their respective owners means installation of various packages and working with packages easier! ) is an all in one powerful testing tool according to your.. Specific technology based application which needs a browser and retrieves the results since Protractor. Sometimes, testers sometimes get stuck between two automation testing tools use external JavaScript libraries to capture page save... And can work comfortably with locators would be the following: Selenium works great testing. Automated web testing tool the images are displayed or not help of Selenium says that: protractor-beautiful-reporter... Comes with parallel execution of tests, simultaneously on multiple browsers and platforms for web applications, widely for!, Safari, IE11, Edge would be the following: Selenium works great for with! The beauty of Protractor basic features and many testers use to record sequence., testers sometimes get stuck between two automation testing of web applications World. Like a real browser default framework jmeter Tutorial: Learn about the tool in a.. To wait for your next test specific technology based application which needs a browser waits using wait... - protractor-beautiful-reporter, protractor-HTML-reporter etc like a real browser, element and by is not comparable as their strategies different. The official JavaScript implementation of Selenium WebDriver install Protractor executing the command: install. Core functionality of Selenium RC carry out full E2E testing that opens a browser do something as long as is... Clear in the market as of now across different browsers and platforms,!